Sunday, January 10, 2010

The underground constipation versus the overhead overflow

One of the pluses of growing up in a city is that you become adept at English. In most cases, kids in school and through college end up picking on at least one other language besides English and their own mother tongue. The educated section of the western world usually holds the Asian population in regard since most Asians can speak at least 2 languages fluently. Many Asians might speak up to 4 languages. As you know, we don’t think it’s a big deal to bump into someone who can handle four languages in India. But to the rest of the world it’s a colossal mark of mass intelligence of a certain geographical pocket; almost like Russians are good at physics, or Koreans are good at math or any of that. It was out of such a train of thought that several jokes emerged, the least of which being: “What do you call a person who speaks many languages? Answer: Multi-linguist. What do you call a person who speaks two languages? Answer: Bi-linguist. And what do you call a person who speaks one language? Answer: American.(well, British and Australian too!)”

Besides the blip-on-the-radar jokes about the English language, there’s no getting away from the fact that English is really what makes life, business, politics, restaurant menus, instructions on condom packets and everything else in between easier to fathom. Yet, in some strange way, there is a big portion of the Indian population that seems to think that it can somehow remain divorced from the Victorian Language. Now we both understand that trying to change someone who isn’t willing to change is like dancing with someone who isn’t willing to dance. It’s called wrestling.

I haven’t tried the English lessons on Tata Sky, but I can say from here that probably the easiest way to get good at English is to first start by being bad at it. That is, I’m assuming, you haven’t been used to speaking it from the days of your kindergarten. Common self-help techniques to learn English that people resort to can be put in two boxes:

The underground constipation: Don’t let the word constipation mislead you into thinking that somehow this one method is bad. This technique usually encompasses reading lots of books and working away at Wrens, Martins and Norman Lewis. It is very important, but this method entails learning the language in isolation. While this might help you say words like ‘incorrigible’ and ‘preposterous’, there is no way you’ll be able to marry the knowledge with the comprehension and its use in day-to-day speech. English really isn’t about saying big words.

The overhead overflow: This is the playground where the real learning happens, and yet most English speaking aspirants never step into it. It is that space where you communicate and talk and exchange information with people who speak better English than we do. The law of physics never falters and a certain degree of osmosis happens between the people exchanging ideas. Over a period of time, hanging around with the eagles actually helps us soar higher than we could have if we continued pecking with the hens.

I write this not as a master of the language, but certainly as a long term student. The words lucid and pragmatic have been giving me a tough time off late. So, if we can somehow find that balance between the underground constipation and the overhead overflow, our ability to communicate in English would be up several notches.

9 comments:

Sridevi said...

Tata Sky provides English lessons?!!
(I am without speech!)

Anonymous said...

Hmmmm , the fact remains that a large section of the urban crowd in India still delve on other languages other than English, atleast it is a bit dominant in the North(no offense, just an observation), basic tendencies of people to switch over conversations in English is not happening, and some wisecracks who think they have mastered the victorian languauge by using some high flying words are going to be really sorry. basic train of thought is not occurring in 'angrezi' in some parts on India and you cant help it. Time will change things for the better.
@Juntas- first when i saw the post title as your gltak status, i thought you were going to write about some problems related to Metro in Bangalore and urban sprawling :D

Arjun B S said...

@Prashlash:

I do agree with you .. but let's not specifically point to the regions where things are more prevalent. There are just as many ppl in the south who are equally lost as well ...

@Sri.. as a matter of fact.. they do!

neet said...

Dei..PETER payyanay..vechhikaren vaa da :D

Gaurav Vashist said...

Loved the line..."to be good in english you have to start with being bad at it".
Its just so so so true....i would like to share a college event with you...In first year i was not at all comfortable with english...infact it used to give me shivers.I tried one ISTE extempore once and i couldn't speak for 20 secs.Audience was about 20 people but still i could not speak.I went to my room and cried as i couldn't face 20 people .So i decided that i have to overcome this fear.I didn't participate in GDs or extempores as i would have surely gone blank.I can not speak what i want to speak,how can i counter argument soemone? So i decided to do anchoring ...i took up small small FORCE events and started to host the events.It was fun i had time to prepare also and no one spoke while i was saying my thing.I improved bit by bit and...yes as you said i have not yet mastered it but still its a long way from where i started.

You have to make a start..norman lewis can help you learn "incorrigible" but to implement it in a best suited context will come by practise and that comes in overhead overflows only.

beautifully put...

Arjun B S said...

@ Gaurav Vashist:

I think it's always a handful of people that overcome fear by taking action! And it paid off in your case :-).. exactly.. even for learning english.. or cooking even.. no recipe book can replace the experience of dirtying your hands and staining your clothes...

Pranab Jha said...

Hi Arjun,
I would like to share my experience. I was also very afraid of speaking in English anywhere. In high-school, I was one of the worst speakers ever. But then I read a line in 'Competition Success Review' that helped me a lot to change my ways. It said that you always speak the language that you think in. So if you want to improve your English, start thinking in English, rather and Hindi or any other language. You know when you think of any situation you always form the words first in your mind. Then that process, over a period of time, becomes swifter and more efficient and you start speaking as you think.
That is how I try to look at it and still trying to learn how to speak fluently in English.

Arjun B S said...

Thanks Pranab for your story! In fact, like you pointed out in the end "still trying to learn how to speak fluently in English" is a very big deal.. the learning part i mean ..

Narayana Swamy K said...

@ sridevi.. Tata sky does do that!!

Its not the big words that make english.. It must be easy to comprehend by the rest of the world! This reminds me of a certain poem written by a certain for a certain college magazine, that certainly could not be understood by anyone!